Indirect speech focuses more on the content of what someone said rather than their exact words.In indirect speech, the structure of the reported clause depends on whether the speaker is reporting a statement, a question or a command.
direct | indirect | reported clause | |
statement |
|
| that-clause |
question |
|
| if-clause/whether-clause wh-clause |
command |
|
| to-infinitive clause |
Indirect speech: reporting statements
Indirect reports of statements consist of a reporting clause and athat-clause. We often omitthat, especially in informal situations:
The pilot commentedthatthe weather had been extremely bad as the plane came in to land.(The pilot’s words were:‘The weather was extremely bad as the plane came in to land.’)
I told my wife I didn’t want a party on my 50th birthday.(that-clause withoutthat) (orI told my wife that I didn’t want a party on my 50th birthday.)
Indirect speech: reporting questions
Reportingyes-noquestions and alternative questions
Indirectreports ofyes-noquestions and questions withorconsist of a reporting clause and a reported clause introduced byiforwhether.Ifis more common thanwhether. The reported clause is in statement form (subject + verb), not question form:
She askedif[S] [V]I wasScottish.(originalyes-noquestion:‘Are you Scottish?’)
The waiter askedwhether[S]we[V]wanteda table near the window.(originalyes-noquestion:‘Do you want a table near the window?)
He asked meif[S] [V]I had comeby train or by bus.(original alternative question:‘Did you come by train or by bus?’)
See also:
Questions:yes-noquestions (Are you feeling cold?)
Whether
Reportingwh-questions
Indirect reports ofwh-questions consist of a reporting clause, and a reported clause beginning with awh-word (who, what, when, where, why, how). We don’t use a question mark:
He asked mewhatI wanted.
Not:He asked me what I wanted?
The reported clause is in statement form (subject + verb), not question form:
She wanted to know who[S]we[V]hadinvitedto the party.
Not: …who had we invited…
Who,whomandwhat
In indirect questions withwho, whomandwhat, thewh-word may be the subject or the object of the reported clause:
I asked themwhocame to meet them at the airport.(whois the subject ofcame; original question:‘Who came to meet you at the airport?’)
He wonderedwhatthe repairs would cost.(whatis the object ofcost; original question:‘What will the repairs cost?’)
The reported clause is in statement form (subject + verb), not question form:
She asked uswhat[S]we[V]were doing.(original question:‘What are you doing?’)
Not:She asked us what were we doing?
See also:
Whom
When,where,whyandhow
We also use statement word order (subject + verb) withwhen,where, whyandhow:
I asked herwhen[S]it[V]had happened(original question:‘When did it happen?’).
Not:I asked her when had it happened?
I asked herwhere[S]the bus station[V]was.(original question:‘Where is the bus station?’)
Not:I asked her where was the bus station?
The teacher asked themhow[S]they[V]wantedto do the activity.(original question:‘How do you want to do the activity?’)
Not:The teacher asked them how did they want to do the activity?
See also:
Questions:wh-questions
Indirect speech: reporting commands
Indirect reports of commands consist of a reporting clause, and a reported clause beginning with ato-infinitive:
The General ordered the troopsto advance.(original command:‘Advance!’)
The chairperson told himto sit downandto stop interrupting.(original command:‘Sit down and stop interrupting!’)
We also use ato-infinitive clause in indirect reports with other verbs that mean wanting or getting people to do something, for example,advise, encourage, warn:
They advised meto waittill the following day.(original statement:‘You should wait till the following day.’)
The guard warned usnot to enterthe area.(original statement:‘You must not enter the area.’)
See also:
Verbs followed by ato-infinitive
Indirect speech: present simple reporting verb
We can use the reporting verb in the present simple in indirect speech if the original words are still true or relevant at the time of reporting, or if the report is of something someone often says or repeats:
Sheilasaysthey’re closing the motorway tomorrow for repairs.
Henrytellsme he’s thinking of getting married next year.
Rupertsaysdogs shouldn’t be allowed on the beach.(Rupert probably often repeats this statement.)
Newspaper headlines
We often use the present simple in newspaper headlines. It makes the reported speech more dramatic:
JUDGETELLSREPORTER TO LEAVE COURTROOM
PRIME MINISTERSAYSFAMILIES ARE TOP PRIORITY IN TAX REFORM
See also:
Present simple (I work)
Reported speech
Reported speech: direct speech
Indirect speech: past continuous reporting verb
In indirect speech, we can use the past continuous form of the reporting verb (usuallysayortell). This happens mostly in conversation, when the speaker wants to focus on the content of the report, usually because it is interesting news or important information, or because it is a new topic in the conversation:
Rorywas tellingme the big cinema in James Street is going to close down. Is that true?
Alexwas sayingthat book sales have gone up a lot this year thanks to the Internet.
See also:
Indirect speech: reporting statements
Backshift
‘Backshift’ refers to the changes we make to the original verbs in indirect speech because time has passed between the moment of speaking and the time ofthe report.
direct speech | indirect speech |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In these examples, the present (am) has become the past (was), the future (will) has become the future-in-the-past (would) and the past (happened) has become the past perfect (had happened). The tenses have ‘shifted’ or ‘moved back’ in time.
Backshift changes
direct | indirect | |
present simple | → | past simple |
present continuous | → | past continuous |
present perfect simple | → | past perfect simple |
present perfect continuous | → | past perfect continuous |
past simple | → | past perfect simple |
past continuous | → | past perfect continuous |
future (will) | → | future-in-the-past (would) |
past perfect | ↔ | past perfect (no change) |
The past perfect does not shift back; it stays the same:
Direct speech | Indirect speech |
He asked: ‘Hadthe girls alreadyleft?’ |
|
Modal verbs
Some, but not all, modal verbs ‘shift back’ in time and change in indirect speech.
direct speech | indirect speech | change | |
will |
|
| willbecomeswould |
shall |
|
| shallusually becomeswould in reported questions,shallbecomesshould |
can |
|
| canbecomescould |
may |
|
| may(possibility) becomesmight may(permission) becomescould |
must |
|
| must(obligation) usually becomeshad to must(speculation) does not change |
could |
|
| no change |
should |
|
| no change |
would |
|
| no change |
might |
|
| no change |
need |
|
| no change |
We can use a perfect form withhave+ -edform after modal verbs, especially where the report looks back to a hypothetical event in the past:
He said the noisemight have beenthe postman delivering letters.(original statement:‘The noise might be the postman delivering letters.’)
He said hewould have helpedus if we’d needed a volunteer.(original statement:‘I’ll help you if you need a volunteer’or‘I’d help you if you needed a volunteer.’)
Used toandought todo not change in indirect speech:
She said sheused tolive in Oxford.(original statement:‘I used to live in Oxford.’)
The guard warned us that weought toleave immediately.(original statement:‘You ought to leave immediately.’)
No backshift
We don’t need to change the tense in indirect speech if what a person said is still true or relevant or has not happened yet. This often happens when someone talks about the future, or when someone uses the present simple, present continuous or present perfect in their original words:
Hetoldme his brotherworksfor an Italian company.(It is still true that his brother works for an Italian company.)
Shesaidshe’sgettingmarried next year.(For the speakers, the time at the moment of speaking is ‘this year’.)
Hesaidhe’sfinishedpainting the door.(He probably said it just a short time ago.)
She promised she’ll helpus.(The promise applies to the future.)
Indirect speech: changes to pronouns
Changes to personal pronouns in indirect reports depend on whether the person reporting the speech and the person(s) who said the original words are the same or different.
direct | indirect | |
|
| different speakers (Ichanges tohe) |
|
| same speaker (no change) |
|
| different speakers (youchanges toshe) |
|
| same speaker (no change toI;youchanges tohe) |
Indirect speech: changes to adverbs and demonstratives
We often change demonstratives (this, that) and adverbs of time and place (now, here, today, etc.) because indirect speech happens at a later time than the original speech, and perhaps in a different place.
direct speech | indirect speech |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Typical changes to demonstratives, adverbs and adverbial expressions
direct | indirect | |
this | → | that |
these | → | those |
now | → | then |
yesterday | → | the day before |
tomorrow | → | the next/following day |
two weeks ago | → | two weeks before |
here | → | there |
Indirect speech: typical errors
The word order in indirect reports ofwh-questions is the same as statement word order (subject + verb), not question word order:
She always asks mewhere[S] [V]I amgoing.
Not:She always asks me where am I going.
We don’t use aquestion mark when reportingwh-questions:
I asked him what he was doing.
Not:I asked him what he was doing?